🔗 Share this article

Ministers have ruled out establishing a open probe into the IRA's 1974-era Birmingham city pub attacks.

This Horrific Attack

On 21 November 1974, twenty-one people were lost their lives and 220 wounded when explosive devices were set off at the Mulberry Bush pub and Tavern in the Town venues in Birmingham, in an incident commonly accepted to have been planned by the Irish Republican Army.

Legal Consequences

No one has been convicted over the bombings. In 1991, six defendants had their guilty verdicts reversed after spending more than 16 years in detention in what stands as one of the most severe errors of justice in UK history.

Families Campaign for Truth

Loved ones have for decades campaigned for a open probe into the bombings to discover what the authorities knew at the time of the tragedy and why not a single person has been held accountable.

Government Decision

The security minister, Dan Jarvis, said on recently that while he had sincere sympathy for the loved ones, the administration had concluded “after careful deliberation” it would not authorize an probe.

Jarvis said the authorities thinks the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery, established to examine deaths related to the Northern Ireland conflict, could investigate the Birmingham bombings.

Campaigners React

Advocate Julie Hambleton, whose 18-year-old sister Maxine was murdered in the explosions, said the decision demonstrated “the government don't care”.

The sixty-two-year-old has long fought for a public probe and explained she and other grieving relatives had “no intention” of taking part in the new body.

“We see no real impartiality in the commission,” she remarked, explaining it was “equivalent to them assessing their own work”.

Calls for Document Disclosure

Over the years, grieving families have been demanding the publication of documents from government bodies on the incident – especially on what the authorities knew before and after the attack, and what evidence there is that could bring about arrests.

“The entire UK government system is against our families from ever knowing the truth,” she said. “Exclusively a legally mandated judge-directed open investigation will grant us access to the papers they assert they do not possess.”

Official Powers

A legally mandated national probe has particular legal capabilities, encompassing the authority to compel witnesses to testify and reveal evidence related to the probe.

Prior Hearing

An inquest in 2019 – campaigned for grieving relatives – determined the those killed were murdered by the IRA but failed to identify the names of those accountable.

Hambleton said: “Government bodies informed the presiding official that they have no files or documentation on what continues to be Britain's longest open atrocity of the 20th century, but at present they intend to push us down the route of this investigative body to disclose evidence that they state has not been present”.

Political Criticism

Liam Byrne, the MP for the Birmingham area, labeled the government’s announcement as “deeply, deeply unsatisfactory”.

Through a statement on social media, Byrne said: “After such a long period, so much suffering, and so many disappointments” the loved ones merit a process that is “autonomous, judge-led, with complete capabilities and fearless in the quest for the facts.”

Ongoing Grief

Reflecting on the families' enduring pain, Hambleton, who leads the Justice 4 the 21, stated: “Not a single family of any horror of any sort will ever have resolution. It doesn’t exist. The grief and the grief remain.”